Home › Food tours › Key West
Food tours in Key West: what to eat and which tour to book
Key West is the last island of the Florida Keys, closer to Havana than to Miami, and its food reflects both: Caribbean seafood, Cuban coffee and sandwiches, and Key lime pie, the town's signature dessert. Local fishing boats land pink shrimp, grouper, hogfish, snapper and mahi-mahi, and in season (mid-October to early May) stone crab claws. Conch fritters are on every menu, though the conch itself is imported because harvesting queen conch in Florida has been banned for decades. Duval Street is the busy bar strip; the Historic Seaport, Bahama Village and nearby Stock Island are where much of the better seafood is.
Use this page to decide what to order and where, with rough 2026 prices in US dollars before tax and tip. The tours shown are real GetYourGuide listings, with prices as seen when we checked; confirm the price and meeting point on the booking page before you pay.
What to eat in Key West
| Dish | What it is | Where to eat it | Typical price* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Key lime pie | A pie of Key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk and egg yolks in a graham-cracker crust, topped with whipped cream or meringue. The real filling is pale yellow, not green. Some shops sell it frozen and dipped in chocolate on a stick. | Bakeries, pie shops and most restaurants across Old Town. | roughly $8–12 a slice |
| Conch fritters | Deep-fried balls of chopped conch in a seasoned batter, served with a dipping sauce. The conch is imported, usually from the Caribbean, since queen conch can't be harvested commercially in Florida. | Seafood shacks and bars around the Historic Seaport and Duval Street. | roughly $12–18 a basket |
| Cuban coffee and Cuban sandwich café con leche / cafecito / Cuban mix | Strong, sweet Cuban espresso (cafecito) or café con leche, and the Cuban sandwich: roast pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles and mustard pressed in Cuban bread. A legacy of Key West's long Cuban community. | Cuban cafés and coffee windows in Old Town and Bahama Village, usually in the morning. | about $2–5 for coffee; $12–16 for a sandwich |
| Key West pink shrimp pink shrimp | Sweet pink shrimp caught in the waters around the Keys, served peel-and-eat, steamed with Old Bay, fried or in tacos. | Seafood restaurants and raw bars at the Historic Seaport and on Stock Island. | roughly $16–28 for a plate or pound |
| Stone crab claws stone crab | Cooked, chilled claws cracked at the table and eaten with mustard sauce. Fishermen remove the claws and return the crab to the water, where the claws can regrow. Only available in season, from 15 October to 1 May. | Seafood restaurants and fish markets during the season; usually 'market price'. | market price, roughly $40–80+ depending on size and quantity |
| Fresh fish sandwich grouper / hogfish / mahi sandwich | Local fish grilled, blackened or fried on a bun with lettuce and tartar sauce. Hogfish, a reef fish usually caught by spearfishing, is a Keys favourite. | Seafood shacks and fish houses, including on Stock Island. | roughly $18–28 |
| Smoked fish dip | A creamy spread of smoked local fish (often wahoo, mahi or amberjack), served with crackers, jalapeños and hot sauce. | Bars, raw bars and seafood restaurants all over the island. | roughly $12–18 |
| Conch chowder | A tomato-based (Bahamian style) or creamy soup with chopped conch, potatoes and vegetables, often spiked with sherry or hot pepper. | Seafood restaurants around Old Town. | roughly $8–14 a cup or bowl |
Where to eat: markets and neighbourhoods
Key West Historic Seaport (Key West Bight)
The working harbour with the Harbor Walk, charter boats, raw bars and seafood restaurants on the water. The best place in Old Town for shrimp, fish and conch.
Duval Street
The main strip from the Gulf to the Atlantic, with bars, live music, Key lime pie shops and casual restaurants. Lively at night, but the food is mostly average and pricey.
Bahama Village
Historic Bahamian and Afro-Caribbean neighbourhood west of Duval around Petronia and Whitehead streets, with Cuban and Caribbean cafés and casual restaurants.
Mallory Square
Famous for the nightly Sunset Celebration with street performers and food carts selling conch fritters, Key lime treats and drinks.
Stock Island
The island just east of Key West, with working fish docks, fish markets and waterside seafood restaurants where many locals prefer to eat.
Food tours in Key West compared
Every tour below is a real listing on GetYourGuide or Viator, checked on 2 Oct 2026. Prices move with season and group size, so treat them as a guide and confirm on the booking page.
| Tour | Length | Price* | Group | Best for | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Key West: Cooking Show Chef Demonstration with Meal | 75 minutes - 2 hours | from €81 per person | — | Travellers who want to cook the dishes again at home; easiest option for dietary needs, since you control the ingredients. | Check dates |
| Key West Signature Sunset Cruise with Open Bar, Food & Music | 2 hours | from €71 per person | — | Evening eaters who want dinner and drinks rolled into one, plus the city after dark. | Check dates |
| Key West: Sunset Dinner Cruise with Open Bar & Live Music | 2 hours | from €83 per person | — | Evening eaters who want dinner and drinks rolled into one, plus the city after dark. | Check dates |
| Key West: Cuban and Caribbean Food and Cultural Walking Tour | 3 hours | from €80 per person | max 7 | First-timers who want a broad tasting of the classics with a local guide. | Check dates |
| Key West: 2.5-Hour Duval Street Pub Crawl | 2.5 hours | from €38 per person | — | First-timers on a budget who want to try many cheap dishes in one go. | Check dates |
| Key West: Seafood and Seaport Walking Tour with 5 Tastings | 3 hours | from €80 per person | max 7 | First-timers who want a broad tasting of the classics with a local guide. | Check dates |
Key West: Cooking Show Chef Demonstration with Meal
On GetYourGuide · run by Historic Tours of America** - Key West
- Length
- 75 minutes - 2 hours
- Price
- from €81 per person
- Rating
- 5.0 ★ from 3 reviews (on 3 Oct 2026)
- Included
- Interactive cooking demonstration by expert chefs Tasting of prepared dishes Recipes to take home History and tales of Key West’s culinary heritage Hand Crafted Sangria Cuban Coffee (morning class) Lemonade Iced Tea W…
- Suits
- Travellers who want to cook the dishes again at home; easiest option for dietary needs, since you control the ingredients.
- Starts
- 291 Front St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
Key West Signature Sunset Cruise with Open Bar, Food & Music
On GetYourGuide · run by Sunset Watersports Key West
- Length
- 2 hours
- Price
- from €71 per person
- Rating
- 4.6 ★ from 509 reviews (on 3 Oct 2026)
- Included
- Food and drinks Live music Tips Transportation to/from the meeting point
- Suits
- Evening eaters who want dinner and drinks rolled into one, plus the city after dark.
Key West: Sunset Dinner Cruise with Open Bar & Live Music
On GetYourGuide · run by Sunset Watersports Key West
- Length
- 2 hours
- Price
- from €83 per person
- Rating
- 4.5 ★ from 294 reviews (on 3 Oct 2026)
- Included
- Buffet dinner Open Bar Live music Sunset cruise Gratuities
- Suits
- Evening eaters who want dinner and drinks rolled into one, plus the city after dark.
- Starts
- 201 William St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
Key West: Cuban and Caribbean Food and Cultural Walking Tour
On GetYourGuide · run by Key West Food Tours
- Length
- 3 hours
- Price
- from €80 per person
- Rating
- 4.8 ★ from 155 reviews (on 3 Oct 2026)
- Group size
- max 7
- Included
- Five food tastings Local guide Guided walking tour of historic Old Town E-guide booklet of Key West with neighborhood dining recommendations Signature e-recipe collection Shopping coupons and discounts at partnering r…
- Suits
- First-timers who want a broad tasting of the classics with a local guide.
- Starts
- El Siboney Restaurant
Key West: 2.5-Hour Duval Street Pub Crawl
On GetYourGuide · run by Key West Promotions Inc
- Length
- 2.5 hours
- Price
- from €38 per person
- Rating
- 4.6 ★ from 66 reviews (on 3 Oct 2026)
- Included
- Entrance fees Five cocktails Guided tour Souvenir t-shirt Gratuities Food
- Suits
- First-timers on a budget who want to try many cheap dishes in one go.
- Starts
- 424 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040, USA
Key West: Seafood and Seaport Walking Tour with 5 Tastings
On GetYourGuide · run by Key West Food Tours
- Length
- 3 hours
- Price
- from €80 per person
- Rating
- 4.9 ★ from 56 reviews (on 3 Oct 2026)
- Group size
- max 7
- Included
- 6 seafood or drink tastings (enough for a hearty lunch) Guided walking tour of the seaport led by a passionate local E-guide of Key West with neighborhood dining and attraction recommendations Signature e-recipe colle…
- Suits
- First-timers who want a broad tasting of the classics with a local guide.
- Starts
- Eaton Street Seafood Market
Some links on this page are partner links. If you book through them TonyPlan earns a small commission — the price you pay is exactly the same.
Street food, sit-down or a cooking class?
Street food
Key West doesn't have a big street-food scene; quick food means Cuban coffee windows, sandwich counters, fritters from seafood shacks, Key lime pie on a stick and food carts at Mallory Square at sunset.
Sit-down meals
Most eating is casual sit-down: open-air seafood shacks, raw bars and island-style restaurants, plus a few upscale places. Expect resort prices. Dinner is from about 18:00; at sunset, waterfront tables fill quickly, so reserve or arrive early.
Cooking classes
Cooking classes are rare; the more common food activities are walking tours that combine tastings with the island's history, occasionally hands-on Key lime pie sessions. Check current schedules, as they change seasonally.
How much to budget for food
| Style | Per person, per day* |
|---|---|
| Budget (street food, markets) | $45–65 (about €40–58): Cuban coffee and sandwich, a fish taco lunch, a cheap dinner |
| Mid-range (one sit-down meal a day) | $90–140 (about €80–125): seafood lunch and a sit-down dinner with a drink, including tip |
| Splurge (tasting menus, wine) | $200+ (about €175+): stone crab or a fine-dining dinner with wine |
Vegetarian, halal and gluten-free
Vegetarian & vegan: Workable: most restaurants have salads, veggie burgers or pasta, and there are a few vegetarian and vegan cafés. Fritters, chowder and many sides contain seafood or meat, and Cuban beans and rice can be cooked with pork.
Halal: Halal food is very limited in Key West. Seafood is the easiest option; Cuban dishes often contain pork.
Gluten-free: Generally good awareness in US restaurants; ask for grilled rather than fried fish, and corn tortillas for tacos. Fritters, Key lime pie crusts and Cuban bread contain wheat.
Food scams and tourist traps to avoid
- 'Market price' stone crab or lobster with no price stated until the bill arrives. Ask what the market price is today and how many claws or ounces you get before ordering.
- Bright green 'Key lime pie' made with food colouring and bottled lime juice. Real Key lime pie is pale yellow; buy from bakeries and restaurants known for making it on site.
- Duval Street drink specials with small print, and automatic gratuity added on top of the tip line. Check the drink price and the bill for an 'auto-gratuity' or service charge before tipping again.
- Free drinks or discounted activities in exchange for attending a timeshare presentation. Decline street offers of 'free' tickets or meals that require a sales presentation.
Top tours & activities in Key West
Rent a car in Key West
Compare rental cars from local and international companies, with free cancellation on most bookings.
Compare car rentals in Key WestPlan the rest of your Key West trip
Staying near the markets saves time and taxi money — most food tours start in the old centre.
Common questions
How much should I tip in Key West?
As elsewhere in the US, about 18–20% at sit-down restaurants, $1–2 per drink at bars, and something for counter service if you like. Some places add an automatic gratuity, especially for groups, so check the bill. Food tour guides usually receive about 15–20% of the tour price.
Is the conch in Key West local?
No. Commercial and recreational harvesting of queen conch has been banned in Florida since the 1980s to protect the species, so conch on Key West menus is imported, mostly from the Caribbean. It's still a classic part of local food, especially fritters and chowder.
When is stone crab season?
Florida's stone crab season runs from 15 October to 1 May. Outside those dates, restaurants shouldn't serve fresh stone crab claws. Prices vary with size (medium to colossal) and the catch, and are usually listed as market price.
Where is the best Key lime pie?
Everyone has a favourite, and many bakeries claim the title. Look for a pale yellow filling made with real Key lime juice, a graham-cracker crust, and whipped cream or meringue on top. Trying a slice from two or three places is part of the fun.
How much should I budget for food per day?
Key West is expensive. Plan roughly $45–65 a day on a budget, $90–140 for two sit-down meals with a drink, and $200 or more for stone crab or fine dining. Florida sales tax plus local taxes and tips add substantially to menu prices.
Do I need to book restaurants?
For sunset dinner on the water and popular restaurants on weekends and in high season (roughly December to April), yes. Casual seafood shacks and bars usually don't take reservations; arrive before sunset or after 20:00 to avoid long waits.
* Prices are approximate, gathered on 2 Oct 2026 from menus, markets and the booking pages linked above. They change with season and exchange rates.